
NBC News
One of the five protesters being arrested on Capitol Hill Thursday.
Five protesters linked arms, sat on the floor blocking a hallway, and chanted slogans against Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid and Planned Parenthood today in the Hart Senate Office Building on Capitol Hill near Sen. Reid's office. They shouted things like:
"Harry Reid is a killer!"
"Abortion is murder!"
"No compromise! Defund Planned Parenthood."
One among the five made it clear that social issues should be part of the on-going budget discussions on Capitol Hill... even as the federal government is one day and a few hours from shutting down.
The protesters are from a group called The Society for Truth and Justice. A spokeswoman for the group made their goal as clear as crystal telling NBC News:
"Congress must stop funding the Planned Parenthood criminal syndicate, the nation's largest child killer and aider of child sex traffickers and child molesters. By continuing funding for Planned Parenthood, the Democrats collaborate with child killers, child molesters, and sex traffickers, which is a threat to both the born and pre-born. It is time for the Democrats to really protect women and girls by defunding Planned Parenthood now."
"It is time for the Democrats to really protect women and girls by defunding Planned Parenthood now."
According to Planned Parenthood's own breakdown of its numbers, in 2009 abortions accounted for three percent of the services the group provided. That's right... three percent. Thirty-five percent of Planned Parenthood services were various kinds of contraception. Another thirty-five percent went to the testing and treatment of sexually transmitted diseases and infections. Sixteen percent of Planned Parenthood's 2009 services went to cancer screening and prevention and another ten percent to other women's health services (pregnancy tests, prenatal treatment, etc.).
But these protesters are focusing only on three percent of what Planned Parenthood does. Lawrence will talk more about this in tonight's Rewrite on The Last Word (8PM ET/PT).





Leave Planned Parenthood alone. 97% of their work doesn't have anything to do with abortion. If you'd pay attention you'd know that. If you don't want an abortion, don't have one, but you have absolutely NO RIGHT to tell me what to do with my body. The sooner you learn that, the better.
Cindy_S,
I was one of the five arrested outside Reid's office.
You know, your words have been making me think: we should leave PP alone; after all, (according to the Guttmacher Institute) they only kill about 320,000 babies per year. No big deal. Thanks for setting me straight on this. I feel like i've been set free.
Hey, Gary. You're absolutely wrong. They don't kill any babies.
Grae,
I get i! The unborn babies are mere blobs of flesh, less important than, say, little puppies or little kittens before they're born.
PP definitely doesn't kill Babies. Definitely not. Abortion refers to the removal of malignant tumors that occur in a female's womb. Thank God that PP is there to remove the cancerous growths in so many women! Wow. they save over 300,000 women from those cancerous tumors! PP IS AWESOME!
Keep on repeating those words of yours to yourself: PP doesn't kill babies! Strawberry fields forever!...remember how John Lennon said it: "living is easy with eyes closed..." It's a great song, don't you think?
By definition, a fetus is not a baby. Stop being so condescending and trying to inflict your version of religion on others and maybe people would take your opinions seriously.
I think Gary needs to call his handlers to get him a new script....
I truly dislike holy rollers, and I'm an ordained minister. Go figure. His version of "Christianity" has very little to do with Christianity as practiced by those who have actually read, and understand, the Bible. It's one thing to hold beliefs and preach them (ie speak and hold conversations with others), it's something completely different when you proselytize and inflict your beliefs on others. The former is what Christians do, the latter is how tyrants act.
mikebank, and Grae,
Mike, is that all you can say in response? Rather lame.
Grae, your idea of preaching keeps you talking to yourself in a closet. Hope you enjoy listening to yourself. God have mercy on anyone who puts up with you as their ordained minister. You despair of Truth, then you teach others your cynicism. You despair of Jesus' Lordship. Nice work! Wow. Where did you buy your "ordination?" Online? And did you get it for a good price?
You tyrant, you are in favor of child-killing by abortion. You are playing "God" and determining who gets to survive the womb, and who doesn't. Stop your deceit. Your views are those of all great tyrants: "get rid of the undesirables." You inflict your tyranny of relativism on the babies. They must die, so that you can continue your pretension to God's throne. Please shut your mouth and let the babies live, not just the ones you-'in your Godly wisdom'--deem worthy of earthly existence.
Gary, You are right, it is lame, but true.
That's all you got, Gary? Personal insults and tyrannical attitudes? Please stop requiring women to be nothing more than incubators. Stop caring only about the contents of the womb and ignoring the living breathing people after they have left the womb.
The Bible says "And the LORD God formed man [of] the dust of the ground, and breathed into his nostrils the breath of life; and man became a living soul." (Gen 2:7) Man gains a soul when he takes his first breath.
Further - "If men struggle with each other and strike a woman with child so that she has a miscarriage, yet there is no further injury, he shall surely be fined as the woman's husband may demand of him, and he shall pay as the judges decide. But if there is any further injury, then you shall appoint as a penalty life for life, eye for eye, tooth for tooth." Ex. 21:22-25. this is one of the laws of Moses. What did Jesus say about Moses? "Think not that I am come to destroy the law, or the prophets: I am not come to destroy, but to fulfil. For verily I say unto you, till heaven and earth pass away, one jot or one tittle shall in no wise pass away from the law, till all things be accomplished." Matthew 5:17-18. We have, on the one hand, The Laws of Moses which says that if the woman dies, kill the man, but not the fetus. Life for Life. Then we have, in Jesus' words, giving an absolute, unqualified endorsement of the teachings of Moses.
I ask you, Gary, why do you hate the teachings of Jesus? Why do you pretend to be a "Christian" and not live as a Christian as taught? You proclaim you religion proudly (wait, pride is a sin) and arrogantly assume you know the heart and minds of others (I believe that would be hubris, another mortal sin). You are certainly not living and following the teachings of the One you proclaim to follow. That would mean you are lying and taking the name of the Lord in vain. That's 3 mortal sins. You've got some 'splaining to do.
Dear Grae,
You are but the latest in a long line of folks who have used Holy Scripture to justify their violence against the innocent and defenseless. For example, you follow the proud tradition of the Plantation owners in 19th century America who used scripture to justify using and abusing slaves.
By your reasoning, one minute before the baby is born, its not a human. Tell me, what about the Pre-mies, those babies born even months before it was time? Will you say that their moms gave birth to blobs of flesh? You have no standard for judging when life begins. Please study Luke chapter one and two. When the Blessed Virgin Mary became the bearer of Jesus, at the announcement from archangel Gabriel, only three or four days later, she, being pregnant, arrives to help Elizabeth. What did the BABY John the Baptist do in Elizabeth's womb? He leapt for joy at the PRESENCE OF THE LORD in Mary's womb. Jesus, only three days old (maybe a few hundred cells, at most), had that effect on the BABY John (not blob). READ THE GOSPEL. AND STOP JUSTIFYING MURDER WITH HOLY SCRIPTURE. Learn Psalm 139. The Lord tells us "Before you were born I knit you in your mother's womb."
I fear I am tossing pearls to swine. I hope you take these Scripture passages seriously.
On another note: Somewhere in the Bible it says "Thou shalt not murder." Please bear that in mind. And remember, Jesus is recorded as saying "follow the commandments." Jesus also said, "He who loves me will keep the commandments."
I'm going away on a trip. I will be unable to respond, although I would like to. I will keep you in prayer. Please ask God directly what he thinks about the unborn. Ask Him directly in prayer. ASK Him! At least, stop spewing your murderous lies about the Sacredness of human life.
God bless you. Please keep me in your prayers. Thank you.
Gary
These people are idiots.Put them in jail and throw away the key. They have no say in personal decisions between me and my doctor - whether he's associated with Planned Parenthood or not. Keep the funding for Planned Parenthood.
I agree. Keep murdering the babies! Let's celebrate the right to murder! Go PP!!!
Putting this story up is lending legitimacy to the protesters and that we should take them serious.
That's right, we definitely should not take child-killing seriously. thanks for your input Mike!
This rethuglican is just like all the rest, they LIE, CHEAT, and they are just plain mean...
These protesters need to go to their neighborhood Hospital, because the numbers show that more abortions are done each day in Hospitals and Doctors offices than in Planned Parenthood. This entire thing is by the Church who wants totaly control of each and every aspect of Reproduction in this country. They want to block the use of contraception and block the idea of education. They want to insure that Babies are born, and then leave the parent and the child to fend for themselves.
Thanks so much, Lawrence, for standing up for Planned Parenthood. Your passion for PP is very appreciated. Thanks for making sure the facts get out there!
Lawrence and Janet,
Ahh, thank you both!! You help me forget about those 320,000 babies that PP murders each year. Strawberry fields forever! You guys are the greatest. Thank you!
Spamalot?
thinkalot? fearGodalot?
Why would I fear a figment of your imagination?
Why bother responding? If God is not real, then maybe its best to ignore my words. Or are you troubled by that God-sized hole in your heart that everyone else has, and that only He can fill?
Lawrence, thanks for standing up for Planned Parenthood. We appreciate the support. Your show tonight is totally awesome! Thanks for getting the facts out there!
I can fully appreciate those who express concerns over abortions, but, I really dislike the idea of men feeling that they should make the decisions for each and every individual woman. This issue is a woman's choice, not a man's.
This rethuglican is just like all the rest...
Lie, straight to the camera smiling like a Cheshire cat...
Mercy...
Where were these guys when Dubya flushed our surplus down the toilet...
How much money just went bye bye in Iraq, most of it through Halliburton, the PMC Blackwater guys, construction workers staying in 5 star hotels in Kuwait, being told to run up the the bills, cause the more the spent, the more the company could charge the good 'ol USA...
Mercy,,,
The GOP is screaming real loud to cover the fact that the deficit this country has is attributable to three things: two unpaid for wars from 2001 to 2009, and the Medicare Part D entitlement Program, that the GOP and Bush never paid for. Now that these things are actually included in the books now - remember, Bush left these things out of his budgets all through his two terms - the GOP is screaming loud to cover up their complicity in the deficit they are screaming about and trying to blame every Democrat for. What a bunch of irresponsible, totally negligent, fraudulent bunch of GOP politicians. They lie to protect their own butts, blame everybody else, and then oh by the way, these GOP idiots in the House try to use us, the American, as their fodder to pass their idiotic radical extreme agenda. Even more stupid, they think we are going to let them get away with it. What an absurd bunch of total yahoos. They don't deserve to hold office in any way because they lied to us and they are using us to pass some radical, racial, extreme agenda and these GOP idiots are using us to do it.
While I realize this is a terrible thing to say, it has to be said.If the tea party republicans succeed in defunding planned parenthood plus all the other abortion laws they plan to pass.Are they going to supply wire coat hangers or will the young ladies have to supply thier own?Just as they had to do before Roe V Wade.Also cities will probably need more dumpsters.I am an older male and I can remember this kind of thing taking place.I certainly dont want to see it happen again.
I am neutral on this issue, buy I have a question; how come it is legal to abort a fetus but if a killer kills a pregnant women he is guilty of murder X2?
The answer is you have no clue about the issue. The common law, which is hundreds of years old, provides that if the fetus is viable (capable of living outside the womb) it would be murder. Otherwise, there was no crime to the fetus. Roe v. Wade follows that common law in delineating the rights of the pregnant woman and the state. There is no such common law doctrine that provides life begins at conception; it is strictly a religious issue. Common law is as old as religious doctrines because it has roots in Roman law. The greatest expansion of common law was in England after the Magna Carta. English common law was adopted by the states in their own constitutions and the federal government.
RepubliCON's like them to be born so they can do Post Natal abortions on them. They like to cut the healthcare, food stamps and other childrens programs, guess they are sick and sadistic SOB's and like to watch children suffer after they are born. Makes you wonder why we have one of the rising infant mortality rates in the developed world compared to those with universal health programs. Also how do the reich wing explain away the life expectancy increases in countries with universal care? Canadians now have better life expectancies than we do in the US. Any CONservative care to explain why?
I agree with Mike P. The media needs to stop giving legitimacy to small groups like this. Come on -- it's FIVE protesters - that is hardly a story. They achieved their goal of media coverage and you contributed with this online story and your coverage on The Last Word on Cable. Shame on you.
G.Thomas: The Koch brothers are only 2 people but look at the control they have over the RepubliCON Koch whores. Yup already done. Hope it makes you feel good to be bought and supporting the interests of the Koch's.
I guess your living proof that anyone who earns under half a million a year and supports the CONservatives is delusional. The "one day when I have my millions" crowd who don't have 2 cents to sratch their ass with, but they love to believe the BS they are fed.
hardly a story? after listening to the newly elected tea party House representatives- some of who say that defunding Planned Parenthood has to be on the table- the message is clear. the gov't will shut down because the republicans want to defund planned parenthood. how do you not link this to what is going on concerning the budget when they both occur at the same time? for wanting less gov't, the republicans sure do like gov't on what they consider to be "moral" issues like gay rights or abortion, control of those who they seem to think are "less than" or who can't help them out politically. on the other hand they want less gov't involvement when it comes to regulation of food safety, pollution, wall street and oil. i think there are other places they could find ways to cut the budget other than defunding Planned Parenthood.
I guess your one of the delusional earn under $250K a year Tea Bagging wannabes. Man have the Koch's got you snowed. One of the Koch's sheep herd, bahhhhhh.
I sure wish that Lawrence would put these GOP big mouths that come on their shows in their place. Every single one of them have the same mantra: "we are doing what the American people sent us to Washington to do". That is a lie. These GOP big mouth teabaggers don't represent the American people - because the real American people are not and never will be radicals, right wing extremists who are trying to push through a radical agenda. These GOP teabaggers are big mouths, and they do not represent what is right and what is a real American. They are un-American, they are un-Patriotic, they shoot their mouths off, and they only represent racism, bias, prejudice, and violence. That is not American, and that is not the American people. The GOP is vile and disgusting, and I wish Lawrence would say they do not represent America, only their radical extreme corner of it, and only have loud mouths and lies to show for their little radical world that they dare to think for one minute represents our great country. These people are going in 2012. Let's start a petition to recall each and every GOP teabagger! Let's start a signed petition to Boehner too.
Your an idiot.
I agree. The Tea Party spin is "the American people want this...". I am American and I for one do not want any part of the radical plans of the Tea Party. We need to have a working goverment that HELPS Americans...not punish us for caring about each other. I hope we Americans tell what we really want... speak loudly and clearly at the next election and get the Tea party and other Republicans out of our govenment. They ran on false promises to create jobs..... not to destroy our govenment!
Anti-abortion protesters are living proof that the Tea Party dominates the psychotic voter demographic.
You are all nutbags. I am just so happy you love abortion so much, that is less chance you will reproduce losers into our gene pool. Thank You:)
Kurt and you are living proof that folks with higher IQ's tend to have fewer children but the idiots in society tend to have many of them. It shows the dumbing down of society, by the way how are your 10 brothers and sisters?
stop trying to push your beliefs about abortion on those of us who feel it is none of our business if someone ELSE chooses to have an abortion. someone here said that those who care so much about doing away with abortion have very little to say about the care of the child after it is in this world. are pro-choicers also against birth control, cancer screenings and health care in general for women? some people need title 10 services. it is unfortunate that we live in a world where unplanned pregnancies occur, where poor women and teenagers get pregnant and have children. defunding planned parenthood doesn't deal with these issues, it only makes it worse to say that this is the way it SHOULD be, or this is the way we wish it were, and try to push our beliefs on everybody else. we still have to deal with the reality in this world, and help those who need it.
@Phil, My one Sister and Two Brother's are fine, all college educated professionals. Thanks for asking. How's your momma? You know the one who unfortunately gave birth to you.
I guess the college education they got prevented then from turning out like a Tea sheep like you. Folks who like to poke their noses into what folks did in the bedroom and their reproductive choices used to be called voyeurs or perverts, now they are called CONservatives.
G.Thomas
presidunce obammy?? You aren't someone we have to take seriously, are you? You are insisting on acting the fool...hm..
Thanks G. Phil is not very observent. I really don't have an opinion on Abortion, however, I just wish his mother would have had the courage to abort him.
Kurt I guess they did succeed in leaving you without a brain.
kurt-3183071, you are suspended for a day for violating rule # 1 of the Code of Honor.
Is it a political or religious issue ? We do not yet have a religious theocracy and we supposedly have separation of church and State. More harm has been done to the human race by people insisting on foisting their religious beliefs on others. Is it time to outlaw religion ? Communist countries do it all the time and I think for good reason.
Maybe we should all lock arms and have a sit in protesting religion. From witch trials, burning people at the stake to religious persecution and honor murders there is historical justification.
I believe a person has the right to believe in religion or not and your rights and beliefs end where my nose begins. So keep you nose out of our business and we won't argue for outlawing religion.
Let’s discuss this intelligently… Those who oppose abortion in this country, do so, because they view it as the murder of a human being. Right or wrong, that is their view point. Given that, let us assume that a federally funded institution, like Planned Parenthood, was murdering live human beings. Not a fetus, but a living, breathing human being. Oh, but this only constituted 3% of their overall services. Would you be in favor of your tax dollars supporting this institution? I didn’t think so. How often federally funded abortions take place is not the issue. It is a distraction.
Whether you agree or not with the rationale of these protesters is inconsequential here. The issue isn’t (or at least shouldn’t be) about a woman’s right to choose. It’s about a taxpayer’s right to say, “NO!”. These protesters do not want their money funding something, to which they morally and ethically opposed. That is the issue here. No need to hide from it or twist it. That’s what this is about. Not a woman’s right to choose. If a woman wants to have an abortion done at a private clinic, and have it paid for by her private insurance, then that’s a separate issue.
Now, the Republicans are going about this the wrong way. The idea should not be to completely defund Planned Parenthood. If other necessary health services such as, cancer screenings and contraception are being provided to those that are in a financial struggle, then those are services that should/need to be maintained.
Locking up the protestors and “throw(ing) away the key”, as one commenter put it here, is against the ideals that are the foundation of our Constitution and society alike. These men and woman are no different than the protesters that were in Madison, Wisconsin. Except that the majority of them could be classified as Republicans. Think outside of the left/right paradigm. It’s there to make you see issues in blue and red. Try to see through it, and see things for what they are, and for right and wrong.
As for funding deaths through taxes how about the legal system. How about the tax exempt status of the Florida moron who burns Korans and gets UN folks killed. We do have a death penalty or as some call it Post Natal abortion. Are the same folks protesting those? Nope didn't think so. I personally would prefer not to pay taxes to cover churches. Property taxes are higher for everyone even non-believers to cover their exempt status. We are probably paying for legal help for the morons who got arrested yesterday I'd prefer they sat in the poor house until they could fund their own. I don't want my money going to the Koch's or the other wealthiest in the country. I don't want to pay tax handout's to the oil companies.
If everyone could pick and chose where their tax dollars get spent the system would not be managable. There are some things everyone dislikes.
My advice imagine your money pays for the churches and I'll imagine my money goes to planned parenthood. There we both can sleep a little easier now can't we while paying our taxes.
Is this the same group that is so religious and pious that also wants to deny health care to the young, elderly and poor ? And I object to their tax exempt status. I don't believe in their right to free speech when it is harmful to others.
I also fear bible thumping so call Christians that are any thing but. I put them in the same class as the Taliban. Religious extremists of all persuasions will hopefully end up with their just desserts.
Wait. What? I thought that tighty-righties were all peaceful and law-abiding. I must have gotten that wrong somewhere along the line.
"The Society for Truth and Justice" - Don't you just love the names they give themselves? "Americans for Prosperity" means "Delusioned for Big Oil," "Moral Majority" was, well, neither. Their names are so benign, yet full of patriotic sentiment and needing to prove how wondrously pure they are. Of course, their names bear no resemblance to reality, but they keep hoping to fool the masses.
In honor of their style of naming groups, I've started a new organization called "Orphans For Puppies and Kittens." Send gobs of cash and I'll use to to wage the good fight for whatever I want, the name of the group will have no influence on our actual activities. Why waste a good name?
Phil, my point has nothing to do with the tax exempt status of religious institutions. Even though I agree with you that the government should not be involved in any religion in any way, that is a separate issue. The fact here is that, these protesters aside, many support the defunding of Planned Parenthood, because they don't want their money used for what they view as an unethical and immoral practice. That's their right, and it's the right of these protesters to say whatever they like, regardless of what you and I may think of it. I'm not saying that we should be able to pick and choose what our taxes pay for at an individual level. That is asinine. I'm merely pointing out that protesters, even those mentioned in this story, have the right to spark discussion and debate, which, if enough people support it, can eventually spark legislation. That's the point here.
As far as Becks72 is concerned, when can you determine that someone's free speech is harmful to others? (Aside from the obvious situation of yelling, "Fire!" in a crowded theater). You? Me? The government? That's the slippery slope you go down when you start reserving rights for some and not all. If a man on a corner spews hate speech about racial or social groups, I would argue with him that he was wrong until I died. However, I would also defend his right to make those remarks until my death, as well. As Pastor, Martin Niemöller, stated about the Nazis: "First they came for the Socialists, and I did not speak out --Because I was not a Socialist.
Then they came for the Trade Unionists, and I did not speak out --Because I was not a Trade Unionist.
Then they came for the Jews, and I did not speak out --Because I was not a Jew.
Then they came for me -- and there was no one left to speak for me."
Hey Lawrence
I want to thank you for 2 points in the show tonight
First off, the real truth behind the 'R' view on Planned Parenthood
and reading the Email you received
But most important to me, in reading that Email
you proved once again that you are a true newsman and not
just a news reader, with the compassion that you have displayed
time and time again. I am proud to have moved away from FOX
and really enjoy watching both you and Rachel :) <3
Grae,
I was one of the five arrested. Sen. Reid collaborates with PP, the largest child-killer in the western hemisphere. You do not think that child-killing by abortion has anything to do with "Truth" or "Justice." Better: you do not think. Period. Are you sure that you want to come across as stupid, callous, and self-centered (not to mention diabolical) as that?
The name of your group could be something like "Those who don't give a damn about the murder of innocent defenseless babies." Or maybe "The know-nothing Society" Honestly, three year-olds know more than you when it comes to identifying the CHILD in the mother's womb.
You are sick. You are perverted. God is not mocked. (Gal 6:7). May God save you from your blindness.